Figure 1 is the original figure panel that I created. The creation of this figure panel was described in the methods in order for someone to recreate. Figure 2 was the replicated figure panel that another student created using the methods. Looking at the format of the two figures, the letters labeling each image are different. In figure 1 they are much larger and easier to see than they are in figure 2. The location of the letters also seems to be higher in the original figure panel than they are in figure 2. Starting with image A in both images, the major difference is the map used. Although both are maps of the campus, figure 2 used an older map than figure 1. In figure 2, the design building is not included because the map is outdated. The map in figure 2 also has a black outline around the campus pond where figure 1 does not have this outline. Figure 2 also lacks the red circle and dot that show the location of where the images were taken that is seen in figure 1. Figure 2 also shows a less zoomed in version of the map. There is space shown above the ILC and below the FAC but these buildings are both slightly cut off in figure 1.
Looking at image B in both figures, one major difference is the black patch on the cement. In the original figure panel the black patch is only on the right side of the image but in the replicate the black patch touches both edges of the image. In figure 1, windows on the right side of Morrill can be seen but in figure 2, windows on the left side of Morrill can be seen but not on the right side of the building. The image of Morrill in figure 2 also seems to be taken from a head on view but there is a slight angle in image 1.
Recent comments